🚫 The Dating Roster Is Cancelled: Why Juggling Prospects Might Be Sabotaging Your Love Life

Dr. John De Oca, Dating & Relationship Expert

Once upon a swipe, dating was simple. You liked someone, they liked you, and after a few awkward exchanges and a shared appetizer, you’d decide whether this thing had legs. Fast forward to 2025, and dating has become less about connection and more like managing a fantasy football team.

Welcome to the dating roster—the trend where romantic prospects are lined up like backup singers, each one ready to step in should the lead falter.

It sounds empowering, strategic, even “modern.” But as someone who has studied dating psychology, coached hundreds through heartbreaks and hinge matches, I’m here to tell you: the roster isn’t working.

In fact, it’s probably doing more harm than good.

What Is a Dating Roster?

If you’re unfamiliar with the term, the “dating roster” is essentially the art of seeing multiple people at once, casually and concurrently. It’s based on the premise that you shouldn't “put all your eggs in one basket.”

In theory, it keeps your heart safe, your options open, and your DMs interesting. In reality? It often leads to emotional burnout, shallow connections, and more red flags than a Formula 1 race.

Why People Swear By It

Let’s be fair—the roster isn’t all bad in concept.

People turn to it for seemingly logical reasons:

• To avoid getting attached too quickly.

• To prevent heartbreak by diversifying emotional investment.

• To maintain power dynamics (because apparently, whoever cares less wins?).

And yes, in a world where ghosting is a dating stage and breadcrumbing counts as effort, it can feel smart to play the game with a little more armor.

But that armor comes at a cost.

Here Comes the Science

Studies back this up. A 2020 article in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships found that juggling multiple romantic interests leads to more decision fatigue, emotional detachment, and lower relationship satisfaction.

Basically, when you’re splitting your attention five ways, you’re not connecting with anyone in a meaningful way.

Not to mention the well-known “Paradox of Choice,” which psychologists have been studying for decades. The more options you have, the harder it becomes to commit to just one—because what if someone better is just one swipe away?

Spoiler alert: You’ll never know, because you’ll be too busy searching.

Roster Culture = Emotional Avoidance in Disguise

Let’s call it what it really is: the dating roster is often a trauma response disguised as a strategy.

It stems from:

• Fear of being hurt.

• Fear of vulnerability.

• A scarcity mindset dressed up as abundance.

You don’t want to be rejected by the one person you really like, so you surround yourself with distractions. That way, if it doesn’t work out, you can shrug it off: “No big deal, I’ve got three more on deck.”

But avoidance isn’t healing. It’s just numbing. And over time, it leads to emotional apathy. You start performing on dates instead of showing up authentically. You’re witty, charming, and “chill”—but not really known.

The Hidden Costs of Roster Dating

Let’s break it down:

🧠 Decision Fatigue – You're constantly comparing, evaluating, calculating. It's exhausting.

❤️ Lack of Depth – Intimacy requires presence. You can’t be truly present when your brain is juggling five conversations and remembering whose dog is named what.

🔁 Emotional Burnout – You're constantly "on." Performing. Filtering. Curating. And deep down, you know you're not making space for something real.

📉 Decreased Satisfaction – The more people you date at once, the more you devalue each connection. It's like taste-testing ten wines—you end up with a headache and no clear favorite.

So, What’s the Alternative?

I’m not here to preach instant monogamy after three dates and two espresso martinis. But there’s a middle path: intentional dating.

Here’s what that looks like:

• Date one person at a time with curiosity and clarity.

• Communicate openly about expectations and pace.

• Give people a genuine chance to show up.

• Build connection, not just chemistry.

It’s not about “catching feelings too fast”—it’s about making space for them to exist at all.

Real Talk: Love Requires Risk

Let’s be honest—dating is vulnerable. Always has been, always will be. The roster might protect you from heartbreak, but it also shields you from the beauty of actual connection.

Because love isn’t efficient. It’s not scalable. And it definitely doesn’t work on a rotation schedule.

So the next time you’re tempted to keep a backup on standby “just in case,” ask yourself:Am I dating to connect—or just dating not to feel alone?

The dating roster promised power. But what if real power is saying: I choose to show up fully, even if it doesn’t work out?

Final Word: Cancel the Roster, Choose Realness

In a world obsessed with options, intimacy is the true rebellion.

So delete a few names, clear the emotional clutter, and give yourself (and someone else) a real chance.

Not because you're desperate.

Because you're done playing small in love.

Want more no-fluff dating advice?

Subscribe to my newsletter / follow on Instagram / book a 1:1 session with me / let's connect.